Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

Which do you prefer in a webcomic? 

70%
486 deviants said Nice artwork and a well-paced story: even if uploads are fewer and far between.
16%
113 deviants said Fast and frequent uploads to keep me interested in the story: art cleanliness and pacing be damned.
9%
63 deviants said I won't read any webcomic that doesn't update frequently AND has nice artwork.
3%
18 deviants said Other (comment)
2%
13 deviants said Webcomics ain't my thing, bro.

Devious Comments

:iconmkidkap123:
Mkidkap123 Featured By Owner Nov 10, 2012  Student Digital Artist
as long as its in a timely fashion. i dont wanna have to check because its unorganized. If its every month than let it be every month. i dont want 2 in month and than 0 the next. : D
Reply
:iconrubberyparts:
RubberyParts Featured By Owner Nov 5, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
i gotta say, it's best if it's got a good story, good artwork, a colorful cast of characters, and isn't always letting people guess what's gonna happen next... and end up letting them be right..
Reply
:iconrecycledoj:
recycledoj Featured By Owner Nov 4, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Honestly, I only check on webcomic updates once a month or so, so if the author updates too frequently, it becomes rather overwhelming. :(
Reply
:iconarcanum-ragnarok:
Arcanum-Ragnarok Featured By Owner Nov 3, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
i think it depends on how much content is being released with each update. if we are talking like...1 page/5-ish panels at a time, i would expect updates once a week or once every 2 weeks at the longest. i think id want web comics to be like tv shows. come in seasons and update weekly.
Reply
:iconemeny-kun:
Emeny-kun Featured By Owner Nov 3, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I don't mind the uploads are far behind, I'm a little busy, and feel it can quickly get too much when you upload 3 pages every day.

So I'd rather want you to work really hard on your comic, and upload it when you feel it's ready :)
Reply
:iconnessperez:
nessperez Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012
The schedule should be consistent for the sake of keeping your audience's attention. Even if it has to be every two weeks or so, if the schedule is relatively consistent, the audience will continue to check the comic. You can sacrifice quality a little bit for a quicker schedule, as long as you go back and refine the artwork in a timely manner.

For example: sometimes Coelasquid (Creator of Manly Guys Doing Manly Things) will upload a page that is junk inks or just flats, but she quickly goes back and updates the artwork to completion, all while maintaining a consistent schedule.
Reply
:iconworldsbiggesttruck:
WORLDSBIGGESTTRUCK Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012   Digital Artist
I don't mind infrequent updates as long as there's a RSS feed. I follow a little over 90 comics, so it's nice when I can just go down the list instead of having to memorize a bunch of schedules.
Reply
:iconinitialfantasy:
initialfantasy Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
If the story is good and art is nice, once per week is good. But I'd prefer it to be twice per week.
Reply
:iconpictoshaman:
PictoShaman Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
Well in my experience, I prefer webcomics that are easily accessible and have a time schedule. Ava's Demon is a great Tumblr webcomic with excellent art but updates so infrequently, I would forget about it had I not been watching it on Tumblr.
Reply
:iconsivilala:
Sivilala Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Nice artwork and fast and frequent uploads.
Reply
:iconlambitymoon:
LambityMoon Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012  Student Digital Artist
Artwork and well-pace story! Those are always worth the wait! Perfect examples of this is Lackadaisy Cats and Helvetica! :la:
Reply
:iconnickworcester:
nickworcester Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012  Student General Artist
i just hate waiting forever for one damn page to show up. sure, quality > quantity any day, but there's gotta be enough quantity!
Reply
:iconbrumagem:
brumagem Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012  Hobbyist Artist
To put things in perspective, I still check on Hanna Is Not a Boy's Name to see if Tessa's come back to it. Last update on there was February. Of 2011. Same goes for Daisy Owl.

Time to plug some nifty webcomics I've found recently!

Shortpacked! is really good. You have to read through like 8 years of archives, but it's worth it. It's always well-written, and well-drawn after the first few months or so. It's about people working in a toy store, and the comic alternates between gag-a-day strips and real story-arcs. The characters are original and interesting and do really interesting things.

Monster Pulse is pretty good too. The art isn't too consistent, but I like it the style anyway. It's kind of a sci-fi young-adult thing. These kids are targeted by these energy beings (created by a scientific research firm) that make the kids's body parts (eye, hair, heart, stomach) manifest into this companion-monster thing. The premise doesn't sound all that promising, but the direction it goes in is really interesting.
Reply
:iconthundraforest:
thundraforest Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012
why not a balance between a the two? a comic that uploads somewhat frequently(1-2 weeks) so you don't forget things, and still has relativity clean for the artist making it(i herd comics make you improve like mad so if it starts out sloppy and rushed it wont be for long.)
Reply
:iconkat-nicholson:
Kat-Nicholson Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012  Professional General Artist
I voted other, since I wanted to reply manually ;) lol

Sorry if this response is a bit garbled... my thoughts are a bit "all over the place" on this subject since there are many different ways of looking at it!

I'm a bit weird with webcomics... and a major hypocrite in fact.. MY webcomic :iconthe-ugly-vampire: is terribly drawn (despite the fact that Im a competent, professional artist)! Also until recently it was updated VERY sporadically (literally, I posted only about 20 comic strips over 2 years or so!) If I were trying to attract myself as a target audience, I would have failed miserably! Despite this though TUV still managed to attract a small but perfectly formed fan-base of beautiful people who encouraged me to carry on and showed their support over the months (without ever nagging or pressuring) so after a while I decided I owed it to them to at least make the updates regular! and so the idea of TUVsday (I now update every tuesday) was born! ;) - Now there's even a youtube cartoon in the works.

This is why I say Im a hypocrite: Generally, something has to LOOK nice before I'll even bother taking a look... something about it has to grab my attention.. although some of the best small press comics I've read haven't always been the most polished in terms of artwork! I guess with the web there's always so much stuff you're competing for attention against... it can be trough to get your stuff noticed amongst all the other posts/ads/messages etc we're bombarded with when we're online. ... Even then it doesn't really matter to me if it's updated regularly or not, since I'm more likely to sit down and read through a back-catalogue or LOTS of strips (Like freakangels, which is a complete story online which I read through it all recently... no waiting for updates.. no loosing track w/the story over artist hiatus' etc.. it's excellent btw- I can't recommend it enough!) By reading through a big bulk of strips like this I find I'm able to get into a story/comic better than trying to follow updates page-by-page as they're posted (if that makes sense?). To that end, using TUV as an example again: I'd have still failed to capture my attention since in 2 years I've barely built up a back-log.. but I think TUV is probably more like the "funnies" kinda strip you get in the news papers, than a serious proper webcomic like freak-angles or others (which I guess if compared to print medium would be more like a graphic novel!). TUV is meant to be fun, and I enjoy doing it.. if other people also enjoy it then that's a bonus. :) ... I guess the approach I've taken w/TUV is more like Silent Reaper's stupid fox.. which I DID eventually get into but it too a long time! - I kept seeing those comics springing up in people's favourites for months/years before I actually bothered taking a look at them... they're funny and I enjoy getting them in my inbox but they're not a serious in-depth story like freakangles .. they're more like 1-off strips like TUV/newspaper funnies.

.. I guess it goes to show that so long as characters are appealing enough, and your comic can make someone smile (or cry, or think, whatever your aim is!) it doesn't matter how well drawn they are or how regularly you update. Work for yourself first and foremost, DON'T put too much pressure on yourself! - and if you're happy with/enjoy it, chances are other people will to. :)

I'm always happy to be a sounding board babe, if U wanna chat about this kinda stuff more/need some support or feedback or what have you. :hug: x
Reply
:iconkat-nicholson:
Kat-Nicholson Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012  Professional General Artist
jeeze... I'm sorry for rambling so much!! TT___TT
Reply
:iconneranos:
Neranos Featured By Owner Nov 2, 2012  Student Digital Artist
My priorities are the Story>Artwork>Schedule.
Reply
:iconzarode1505:
Zarode1505 Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
I prefer webcomics that DON'T BURN THEIRSELVES OUT. >_> Also one's that have an ending are awesome.
Reply
:iconendshark:
endshark Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
Had to vote other. Generally I prefer to read comics in print, yet webcomics are certainly also fun to read when I can keep the attention span for it. So I wasn't really able to vote "webcomics aren't my thing" because they ARE and they aren't if that makes any sense at all d00d.

I just have a hard time staying focused and committed to reading a webcomic since the internet can be incredibly distracting. I also find it hard to keep checking for updates all the time, as well as I almost hate reading them off my screen. I like the feel of flipping through pages. But then there are some comics that I read online all the time (VOID battles etc) as well as finding that some comics are just better suited for a web format if they were made with the web in mind. So how often it updates doesn't even really factor in for me because I'll probably forget about it and then just randomly remember it later on.
Reply
:iconsammydilapidated:
sammydilapidated Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012
Well if it's good, there are NEVER enough pages! Raaaar!
But in all seriousness I'd prefer slower updates. Your art is LOVERLY and I'd hate for you to be shovelling out pages you're not happy with just to please the rest of us. But whatever you're comfortable with, it's up to you :heart:
Reply
:iconosanagokoro:
Osanagokoro Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Above all, story and consistency. I don't care about how frequent the posts are, but so long as you stick to whatever schedule you set, I'm gravy. Art quality also takes a backseat--particularly if I get to watch the artist's style develop and/or improve as the comic goes. Gunnerkrigg Court and Questionable Content are excellent examples.
Reply
:iconpinkstar14:
Pinkstar14 Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
While I prefer frequent uploads and don't mind if the art's a little sketchy, I do mind if that affects the story itself; I don't care if you can't erase you're guidelines because you're posting so quick, but you should have written out the script before you began drawing.
Reply
:iconalmy-nol:
Almy-Nol Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012
While I do like a well paced story that's easy to understand, I can also appreciate the complexity of one as well. For example, Nature of Nature's Art is pretty good. It's not something I understand right off the bat, but rereading parts of it allow the story to sink in a bit more, all the while I can take the time to appreciate the art itself.
Reply
:iconalmy-nol:
Almy-Nol Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012
Derp. :P
Reply
:iconteambrownie1:
teambrownie1 Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
a webcomic should be well written, but you should also be happy with your art. take as long as you need, and it'll look better than if you listen to the people who have short attention spans and want it done like THAT.
Reply
:iconjesteppi:
Jesteppi Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist
I follow many webcomics. I like recent updates, I mean who doesn't, but that isn't important to me. I follow them because of their story, not their art skill or how often they upload. (:
Reply
:iconangelcrusher:
AngelCrusher Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Filmographer
Some of the most popular webcomics involve little more than stickmen.

As long as the content is good and the updates are frequent, that is enough. The quality can develop over time if you want, but it isnt a necessity.
Reply
:icondreballin3x:
Dreballin3x Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
It depends on the number of panels per update I guess. For example, the webcomic, Mystery Babylon-Kick Girl, updates every Monday, but since it's in the style of a graphic novel, you only get a small portion of plot each week. However, the art for it is pretty darn good. The others I read update maybe twice a week or so, but are also smaller, newspaper funnies style strips. That means, even if they enter a story arc, each panel ends in a joke and you feel satisfied. I suppose if it were the former style, I'd like it more if multiple pages were uploaded all at once whenever the artist is satisfied with them. Maybe a whole chapter when it is ready. However, if it is the latter, the weekly style is always good and also has nice art (the ones I read anyways). You probably shouldn't try to rush anything though if it's graphic novel style. Your art will definitely slip.
Reply
:iconraygirl:
raygirl Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Filmographer
It honestly depends on the comic. For an evolving storyline full of characters I know and love slowly developing over time, a slower pace is better. I can savour the pages in small bursts.

For more of a 'gag strip' or 'newspaper' comic I like em faster and more regular to enjoy more off in a short space of time. They don't need to be grand works of art on every page, because if you find a strip you don't like it's easy to hop quicky to the next one :D It's why I love Sinfest :)

It's kinda like caramel popcorn compared to a big christmas dinner :D Both are great depending on the circumstances :)
Reply
:iconbombshellboy:
BombshellBoy Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
Well said. c:
Reply
:iconkevintheradioguy:
kevintheradioguy Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Writer
That... might sound... weird, but I'd like you to like the webcomic. Even if it's going to be a sketchy one, and if it takes you a month to draw one single page, you can always see when the author loves the work they do, and this 'love' makes a webcomic amazing.
I'm reading few webcomics here. One of those is a drama about a weasel (!) who came back from war (!!) and it seems like he's starting a romance (!!!), it's a banal plot, the style is a bit sketchy, but the eager and love of the author makes this comics so special, I can't wait to see the next pages. There is... something about this Creator+Creation relationship.
I don't think it takes a schedule, witty plot or exctra-cool art to make comics interesting. There's something more about it, and I'm not sure if it's aint the authors attitude.
Reply
:iconbombshellboy:
BombshellBoy Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
I greatly appreciate your input, thank you. <3 With how much people tend to demand from artists, it's nice to know that there are still a few out there who enjoy the work if an artist enjoys making it.
Reply
:iconanimeshen:
Animeshen Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Filmographer
as much as i wish we could have fast-updating webcomics that are LAOS high in quality with good pacing, thats too hard on the artists. I follow a number of webcomics that update infrequently but have fabulous storytelling and art, and thats how i like 'em. Just as long as updates don't get SO far in between that people forget you draw a comic at all and stop coming back.... like mine lol
Reply
:iconbombshellboy:
BombshellBoy Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
Haha don't worry, I'm in the same boat. :'| If you fall off the wagon, you just gotta chase it down and hop back on.
Reply
:icongreenfrostfire:
greenfrostfire Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012
Personally I think consistency is the most important trait. If you set a scedule fans sorta expect you to keep it and tend to show up less frequently if the comic isn't likely to update on time.
As for frequency and art quality, that all depends on how much of each your planning to use.
If its a daily or five days scedule your considering then quality can usually be buggered. Some artists try using color to hide the mistakes but with those you generally see a fast and steady increase in artistic ability over the period of a year or two.
On the other hand if you mean once or twice a week, then its better to concern yourself more with quality since you will be updating less often and thus want to make something that can keep the readers in.
Reply
:iconbombshellboy:
BombshellBoy Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
Quality is definitely a huge issue with -my- comic. I'm aiming for once a week to start with, if I can meet that easily I'll try for twice a week. Anything more would really be pushing it, especially considering the poor condition my wrists are in.
Reply
:icongreenfrostfire:
greenfrostfire Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012
Yeaaaah~ If weekly is what your trying for then quality is certainly what should take precedence over frequecy.
Reply
:iconkayshae:
Kayshae Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Nice artwork, even if uploads aren't frequent, because I understand that artists sometimes become busy
Reply
:iconpaise:
Paise Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I really like reading comics that issue a page once a week. :aww:
That way, it's kinda like watching a TV show. You can look forward to it all week and you know that it'll be coming out on that certain date. :D

I think a week is also an acceptable amount of time to make a page, maybe even two, depending on the schedule.

I guess for me, even though I haven't read that many, I respect their work ethic and their stick-to-it-iveness. I don't think I'd have the patience or the imagination to do so hahah! ^^;
Reply
:iconrazortoshiba:
RazorToshiba Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist Artist
dat anticipation is a good thing,

if people like it, they'll get more excited if the pages are farther apart,
Reply
:iconjrc1120:
jrc1120 Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist General Artist
Personally, as long as the artwork is nice and clean and the story is flowing at a nice pace, I could care less if the schedule is kept.
Reply
:icondegreesofdeath:
DegreesOfDeath Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I've read the whole range of webcomics. There are some that have updated pretty much daily (which is super fuckin' impressive on its own), one that updates tri-weekly, some that update once a week, and a couple that update "whenever the hell the art's drawn." It all depends on whether I'm interested in the story and, to a lesser extent, if I like the art. Update frequency is probably at the bottom of my priority list.
Reply
:iconwesleyriot:
WesleyRiot Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Filmographer
i clicked " I won't read any webcomic that doesn't update frequently AND has nice artwork." but then I still read Ctrl-Alt-Dlt so that's not strictly true. But it's the reason I won't even look at Questionable Content.
Reply
:iconkingatticus:
KingAtticus Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist Writer
It needs to look good if it's a comic. While story and writing are important, it doesn't matter how great the story is if the comic doesn't look aesthetically pleasing.
Reply
:iconskystalker:
Skystalker Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Student Digital Artist
I don't mind waiting a little for great artwork and story pacing. :D Though I don't read many webcomics, I probably wouldn't read one that took months for every single update. :( I could probably forgive a couple of weeks pretty easily, but it'd just be too painful to see an exciting page and then have to wait like two months to see what happens next umu

Of course, these are just my views. :D It's up to you as the webcomic artist to decide what's best for the comic and what your fans will enjoy! :nod:
Reply
:iconcassidypeterson:
CassidyPeterson Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Hobbyist
Somewhere between good art and good story. A lot of the webcomics I read started out with only passable artwork, but a good enough story to overlook the visual failings. I generally won't go with a bad story and good art, though - I've stopped reading a few webcomics because even with the evolution of the art, I felt the story had gone downhill and wasn't worth reading anymore.

Frequent updates are good, but as long as there are REGULAR updates I'm happy. One of the comics I read only updates once a month.
Reply
:iconwazzup1721:
Wazzup1721 Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012   Digital Artist
It's kinda hard for me to answer. I think it's rude to rush people with their art and comics but at the same time, if I'm made to wait a little too long I will lose interest guaranteed. Buuuut also if the art is phenomenal, I'll most likely be interested again in the future xD
I think as long as the artist is proud of their work, that's what matters
Reply
:iconbombshellboy:
BombshellBoy Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
A lovely response, thank you. :heart:
Reply
:iconroflqu:
RoflQu Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012
I never read webcomics consistently. I always do it spurts, so if a comic is updated regularly or not, I barely ever know.

That being said, it's far more important in this day and age to work on producing something with more quality to it. I would rather a great page a week instead of 3 of them at the cost of quality, especially nowadays when these pieces of work are likely to become a book to sell.
Reply
:iconbombshellboy:
BombshellBoy Featured By Owner Nov 1, 2012  Professional Digital Artist
Agree completely. If something looks and reads like it was rushed to meet a deadline, I tend to want nothing to do with it haha.
Reply
Add a Comment:
 

Poll History